England - Periods - Tudor 1485-1603

The Great Question

Placeholder image

The "Great Question" refers to the issue of the legitimacy of Henry VII's claim to the English throne. Henry VII was the first Tudor monarch, and he came to power after defeating Richard III in the Battle of Bosworth Field in 1485. However, his claim to the throne was not entirely clear, as he was descended from the illegitimate branch of the Plantagenet family.

The Great Question arose because Henry VII's legitimacy was challenged by various pretenders to the throne, who claimed to be the rightful monarchs. The most notable of these was Lambert Simnel, who claimed to be Edward Plantagenet, Earl of Warwick, the legitimate heir to the throne. Another pretender was Perkin Warbeck, who claimed to be Richard, Duke of York, one of the Princes in the Tower who had disappeared during the reign of Richard III.

Henry VII was deeply concerned about the Great Question because his legitimacy was crucial to his ability to maintain power. If his claim to the throne was successfully challenged, it could lead to civil war and the end of the Tudor dynasty. To defend his claim, Henry VII took a number of measures, including marrying Elizabeth of York, the daughter of Edward IV, in order to unite the Yorkist and Lancastrian factions. He also employed a network of spies and informants to detect and root out potential conspiracies against him.

In the end, Henry VII was able to maintain his grip on power despite the challenges to his legitimacy. He ruled England for 24 years and was succeeded by his son, Henry VIII. The Great Question remained a significant issue throughout the Tudor period, however, and the legitimacy of the Tudor dynasty continued to be challenged by various factions and pretenders.

The Great Question and Henry VII's efforts to secure his legitimacy had a significant impact on his son, Henry VIII, and his quest for a male heir. Henry VIII inherited a throne that was still somewhat unstable, with various factions and pretenders continuing to challenge the legitimacy of the Tudor dynasty.

As a result, Henry VIII was acutely aware of the importance of having a male heir to secure the succession and prevent any challenges to his own legitimacy. He famously married six times in his pursuit of a son, and the failure of his wives to provide him with a male heir was a major factor in his decision to break with the Catholic Church and establish the Church of England.

Henry's divorce from his first wife, Catherine of Aragon, was based in part on her failure to provide him with a male heir. He then married Anne Boleyn, who also failed to produce a son and was subsequently executed. His third wife, Jane Seymour, finally gave birth to a son, Edward VI, but she died soon after, and Henry was once again without a male heir.

This led him to marry three more times, but none of his subsequent wives were able to provide him with a son. The failure of his quest for a male heir had significant consequences for England, as it ultimately led to the instability of the Tudor succession and the eventual succession crisis of the Elizabethan era.

York vs Lancaster

The Tudor period was marked by a number of incidents and events that involved the rivalry between the Lancaster and Yorkist factions and potential usurpations of the English throne. Here are some of the most notable:

War of the Roses (1455-1487): The War of the Roses was a series of conflicts fought between the House of Lancaster and the House of York for control of the English throne. The war began in 1455 with the First Battle of St Albans and ended in 1487 with the Battle of Stoke Field. The war resulted in the deaths of many prominent figures, including Richard III, and paved the way for the rise of the Tudor dynasty.

Lambert Simnel (1487): Lambert Simnel was a pretender to the English throne who claimed to be Edward Plantagenet, Earl of Warwick, the legitimate heir to the throne. He was supported by the Yorkist faction, who were unhappy with the rule of Henry VII. However, Simnel's rebellion was crushed at the Battle of Stoke Field, and he was captured and later pardoned by Henry VII.

Perkin Warbeck (1491-1499): Perkin Warbeck was another pretender to the English throne who claimed to be Richard, Duke of York, one of the Princes in the Tower who had disappeared during the reign of Richard III. He was supported by the Yorkist faction and received backing from various European powers. Warbeck's rebellion was initially successful, and he was even recognized as King Richard IV by the Holy Roman Emperor Maximilian I. However, his rebellion was eventually crushed, and he was executed in 1499.

Yorkshire Rebellion (1489): The Yorkshire Rebellion was a popular uprising in northern England that was caused by high taxes and the perception of corrupt government officials. The rebellion was supported by the Yorkist faction, and the rebels even declared their support for the pretender Lambert Simnel. However, the rebellion was crushed by the royal army, and many of the rebels were executed.

Pilgrimage of Grace (1536): The Pilgrimage of Grace was a popular uprising in northern England that was caused by opposition to the religious changes instituted by Henry VIII. The uprising was initially led by Robert Aske and was supported by many members of the nobility and gentry. The rebels demanded a return to traditional Catholic practices and the restoration of the monasteries that had been dissolved by Henry VIII. However, the rebellion was eventually crushed, and many of the leaders were executed.

These incidents and events demonstrate the ongoing tensions and rivalries between the Lancaster and Yorkist factions during the Tudor period, as well as the potential for usurpations of the English throne by pretenders and rebels. The Tudor dynasty was able to maintain its hold on power, but the memory of these conflicts continued to shape English politics for centuries to come.

If you have a suggestion regarding additional topics you would like to see included - please let us know

Reference: Article by Greg Scott (Staff Historian), 2024

i

History & Heritage

Access History creates and posts content, articles, and subject matter relating to history and heritage
Copyright 2025 to Clio Society. All rights reserved and images and logos are created and presented for the general use of the public and educational institutions All content is the responsibility of Access.
Use of this website constitutes acceptance of Access terms and conditions
Placeholder image